While Chris Matthews doesn’t make
my leg tingle (sorry Chris – you won’t live that down until President O is out
of office), he’s not completely objectionable like other hosts on MSNBC. Chris is the only one who routinely has on
guests who disagree with him.
On yesterday’s show he made a
mistake - a mistake of omission for not telling all the facts.
There’s a 40 year old chestnut on
the left that they love to tell – that Democrats were the ones who championed
the 1964 Civil Rights Act into law, over Republican opposition.
That wrong fact was challenged on
the floor of Congress yesterday when Representative Virginia Foxx (R North
Carolina) said this:
The GOP has been the leader in starting good environmental programs in
this country, just as we were the people who passed the civil rights bills back
in the sixties, without very much help from our colleagues across the aisle.
By the way if you’re wonder what environmental
programs were started by Republicans, look up “Environmental Protection Agency”
which was proposed and signed into law by President Nixon.
Chris Matthews, seeing truth
finally entering into the civil rights debate, took exception to Representative
Foxx claiming it was Republicans who passed the Civil Rights Act. Chris put forth this fact in response:
Well here are the facts. 46 Democratic senators voted for the Civil
Rights bill, 46 and 27 Republican senators. Well that's the numbers.
Uh, that’s not quite all the
numbers Chris, is it? Chris didn’t tell
you how many members each party had in the Senate back then. If you think that’s not important, let me
play the same trick on you Chris did by telling you how many Senators voted
“No” on the 1964 Civil Rights Act:
23 Democrats voted no, 6 Republicans
voted no.
Nearly 4x as many Democrats opposed
the 1964 Civil Rights Act as did Republicans!
But don’t let me play the same trick on you that Chris did. His numbers and my numbers don’t tell you the
real story. The percentages do. Let’s look at the percentages to see which
party was united in passing the 1964 Civil Rights Act, and which party had a
huge bloc who wanted to kill the bill.
In the Senate, 80% of Republicans
voted for the Civil Rights Act, while only 69% of Democrats did.
In the House, these were the
Republican votes for and against: 136
for (80%), 35 against (20%).
The House Democrat votes were 165
for (63%) and 91 against (37%).
You have to wonder how Democrats
have traditionally been credited with passing the 1964 Civil Rights Act when
80% of Republicans were for it compared to only 63% of Democrats. I blame bad media and bad school teachers.
If Chris Matthews still isn’t convinced
the 1964 Civil Rights Act was a Republican accomplishment, he should consider
these facts:
·
Senate Democrats filibustered the bill. The left leaning Wikipedia calls it a “brief
filibuster.” If by “brief” Wiki means 3
months and the longest filibuster in Senate history, then yeah, you can call it
“brief.”
·
Senator
Richard Russell, (D-Ga) led the filibuster, and he said: "We
will resist to the bitter end any measure or any movement which would have a
tendency to bring about social equality and intermingling and amalgamation of
the races in our states."
·
Senator Robert Byrd, the Democrat who was a recruiter
for the KKK, talked for 14 straight hours against the bill.
·
Republican Everett McKinley Dirksen championed the cause to break the Democrat
filibuster, with 82% of Republican voting to break it and only 66% of Democrats.
Immediately after Rep. Foxx made
her comments yesterday, Rep. Dennis Cardoza (D-Ca) either made a blunder or
proved that Democrats intentionally revise history. He said:
"It was over the objections of people like Jesse Helms from the
gentlewoman's state that we passed that civil rights legislation."
Civil Rights legislation was
passed in 1964 and 1965. Jesse Helms
took office in 1973.
Another reason people black and
white associate the Civil Rights Act with Democrats is because President
Johnson was a Democrat, and in America
we tend to credit/blame presidents for everything while ignoring the work of
Congress.
For a more recent example of the crediting/blaming
presidents instead of Congress, see President Obama’s endless complaints about
the economy over “the last 8 years.” He,
the media, and many people fail to consider that in January, the Democrats will
enter their 4th straight year of control of Congress, and it’s
Congress who spends the money, not the President.